Was this a good/bad Fantasy Pick?

[vendela99]

Hey guys, drafted my team last night...Very Solid from top to bottom except maybe at QB. Picked Jon Kitna as my qb1 after the first tier qb's were gone. He had more attempts and completions than anyone in the league last year, over 4200 yards and has Roy Williams and Calvin Johnson as targets so I went with the numbers over the bigger names (ie Leinart, Young, Romo, Cutler, etc.). Still I don't follow the Lions and only remember this guy struggling with the Bengals. Can anyone tell me if he's really worth a shit?

[DocJ]

He's typically ranked from #7-10 in most formats. I had him #7 on my cheatsheet. What round did you get him in?

[STUDS]

if ur team does not deduct for int's he's a good pick

i think he'll have 25 td's 20 int 4250 yrds

[Skarhead1]

hes not a bad pick at all.. whos your back up. ho wmany man league is this ?

[vendela99]

Took him in the 6th.

With the 9th selection (12 teams) my draft went:

1. Reggie Bush, RB, NO
2. Willie Parker, RB, PGH
3. Andre Johnson, WR, HOU
4. Roy Williams, WR, DET
5. Deion Branch, WR, SEA
6. Jon Kitna, QB, DET
7. Kellen Winslow, TE, CLE
8. Miami Dolphins D
9. Adam Viniatieri, K, IND
10. Brady Quinn, QB, CLE
11. Fred Taylor, RB, JAX
12. LJ Smith, TE, PHI
13. Rod Smith, WR, DEN
14. NY Jets D
15. Olindo Mare, K, NO
16. Kevin Jones, RB, DET
17. Kevin Walter, WR, HOU

[STUDS]

you stole kj. i hope he comes back

you have a really good team!!

[Skarhead1]

drop rod smith (hes going to be a #3 or 4 and pick up dennis northcut if you can. NC is most likely going to be the #1 in jax this year after williams gets cut

[vendela99]

drop rod smith (hes going to be a #3 or 4 and pick up dennis northcut if you can. NC is most likely going to be the #1 in jax this year after williams gets cut

Thanks for the heads up...I knew Rod Smith was on the outs, but at that point in the draft everyone is obsolete...I'm going to see if Northcut's available.

[DocJ]

So FWParker was the 16th pick! Holy crap, that's amazing.

[vendela99]

So FWParker was the 16th pick! Holy crap, that's amazing.

ha...yah...he fumbled at the goal line in the game last night in the first round of the draft and he's not as well known down here. I was very happy with my Top 5. 2 Star RB's and all WR's are All Pro caliber #1 options on their teams.

My only real second guesses are that I could have picked Leinart or Cutler (I'm a Broncos fan) instead of Kitna, and I could have picked Matt Schaub, QB, HOU (I live in Houston and he is on fire this preseason) instead of Brady Quinn. I went with Quinn because I like the guy, he benches 225x24...fellow lifter, very endearing trait, and Kitna doesn't have a bye until week 6. I think Quinn will be starting by then. Culpepper is still on the waiver wire too.

[DocJ]

ha...yah...he fumbled at the goal line in the game last night in the first round of the draft and he's not as well known down here. I was very happy with my Top 5. 2 Star RB's and all WR's are All Pro caliber #1 options on their teams.

My only real second guesses are that I could have picked Leinart or Cutler (I'm a Broncos fan) instead of Kitna, and I could have picked Matt Schaub, QB, HOU (I live in Houston and he is on fire this preseason) instead of Brady Quinn. I went with Quinn because I like the guy, he benches 225x24...fellow lifter, very endearing trait, and Kitna doesn't have a bye until week 6. I think Quinn will be starting by then. Culpepper is still on the waiver wire too.

You definately made the correct QB1 choice, no question. IMO Quinn will be huge (even on the Browns) once he gets the helm. I'd avoid Culpepper like the plague (I'm from MN).

[STUDS]

culpepper will be comeback player of the yr!!

[DocJ]

culpepper will be comeback player of the yr!!

LOL! Out of which players? Pennington was comeback last year right?

[STUDS]

i knew you'd lol. but i got a feelin the raiders will be a 500 ballclub this year.

i also think lamont will make a big comeback

the have a really good D

they have c-pep, porter, lamont and rhodes. just a hunch

[DocJ]

I agree on Jordan and their pass-D is scary good.

Only one problem...I think I could play on their O-line as a walk on

[PeterPaul]

Took him in the 6th.

With the 9th selection (12 teams) my draft went:

8. Miami Dolphins D
9. Adam Viniatieri, K, IND
10. Brady Quinn, QB, CLE
12. LJ Smith, TE, PHI
13. Rod Smith, WR, DEN
14. NY Jets D
15. Olindo Mare, K, NO
16. Kevin Jones, RB, DET
17. Kevin Walter, WR, HOU

overall a solid draft, but these picks are terrible.

your midround picks 8 to 12 could have been much, much stronger.

[Soul Rebel]

agreed^ You need better a better wideout also after your #1 and #2.